New thinking for budgeting forecasts

Professor Prabhu Sivabalan believes it might be time to rethink the budgeting process.

It’s time to change thinking on traditional budget forecasting and adopt methods that capture non-financial measures and longer-term objectives. Here’s why.

Former British Prime Minister Sir Winston Churchill said the future is just one damn thing after another. Anyone in business with the job of looking ahead knows how true this is, but there are methods that can provide a road map to the future and help finance professionals avoid dead ends and potholes.

The place to start, according to Professor Prabhu Sivabalan, professor of accounting and associate dean – external engagement, at Sydney’s UTS Business School, is to rethink the budgeting process.

Sivabalan believes most organisations struggle with budgeting because the future is always hard to predict and managers generally do not want to make firm on-the-record forecasts.

“There are two intrinsic weaknesses,” he says. “First, there is the inherent difficulty in predicting how the real world will impact the organisation in the future. Second, there is the issue of getting managers and employees to engage with this process in an authentic way. Usually, it is a bit of both.”

Quantifying goals

The most common form of budgeting in Australia is the annual budget, usually structured in a traditional way and broken down through divisions, business units and even teams. Monthly and quarterly rolling budgets are often used alongside annual budgets in larger organisations.

By and large, a budget is the expected financial quantification of a company’s goals, ideally based on a considered reflection of its circumstances. It is then used as a tool to hold managers accountable for a level of performance. In being used to evaluate performance, however, it sets off a chain of incentives that lowers its utility for planning and resource allocation.

“The main weakness is the unyielding focus managers and staff have on over-specifying the use of a budget as a performance evaluation device while missing its value as a planning and management device,” Sivabalan says. 

“These are related, but by overemphasising the evaluation, we ruin planning. Emphasise planning, and you reduce the negativity associated with evaluation.”

Telling employees at any level that their performance assessment – including bonuses – will be judged on adherence to a set of numbers can induce pressure. If targets are too difficult, they naturally discourage creativity and innovation, but the same budget that constrains can also enable. If a looser, more generous research and development (R&D) budget is given, for example, it emboldens staff creativity

Getting ahead of the curve

“It is just human nature to stay with the safe and the known if you are rewarded for doing so,” Sivabalan says.

“What we need is a wider range of performance incentives to take the pressure off budgets as the sole determinant of performance evaluation. My research shows that a lot of companies have a range of financial and non-financial KPIs [key performance indicators] but they do not actually walk the walk when bonus determination time arrives.

Inevitably, staff are rewarded if they hit a financial number, with cursory acknowledgement of their non-financial outcomes.”

At the same time, the executive team needs to be able to look at the larger picture from a forecasting perspective. This means developing an understanding of trends within the industry and the broader economy, emerging technologies and social issues, so that the longer-term objectives of the organisation are met, rather than just its annual profit target.

Resources can then be allocated through the budget process to areas of the organisation most likely to face challenges, or to where there are opportunities to get ahead of the curve.

This can be disruptive, compared to the “steady-as-she-goes” mentality often associated with traditional budgeting.

“It requires bold leadership – a special kind of executive,” Sivabalan says. “You can’t blame most C-suite executives for not taking this on. You initially rock the boat when you incentivise staff based on factors other than budget adherence.”

Choosing metrics

Forecasting methods are sure to vary across industry sectors and the team responsible for looking ahead needs to choose the right metrics and most appropriate timeframe.

Financial institutions, for example, need to look at likely future interest rates and the economic framework with a long horizon. In the retail sector, forecasts are better made on a weekly or monthly basis. However, the fundamental principles of taking a broad view, considering a range of data, and acknowledging uncertainty are universal.

Sivabalan notes there are software tools that can help with forecasting but emphasises they are no substitute for a strategic mindset.

“No software explains uncertainty,” he says. “We have all the technology we need. What is in short supply is a willingness to embrace uncertainty. When you determine budgets at the start of a period, you know they’re likely to be wrong. If you can accept this and work with it, you’re ready to start thinking about smarter ways of benefitting from a budget.”

Sivabalan argues for a pragmatic, planning-based perspective.

“We need to turn budgeting into a forward-looking process where managers adapt to uncertainty when it arises, and not game around it before a period starts by arguing for easy numbers so they get a larger bonus later.”

Professor Sivabalan will speak at CPA Congress in Brisbane, Canberra, Melbourne and Sydney. Find out more.


Like what you're reading? Enter your email to receive the fortnightly INTHEBLACK e-newsletter.

Recommended for You

READ MORE
Improve your Excel moves by converting a budget into a forecast

Convert a budget into a forecast in Excel


READ MORE
Planning is your friend in a chaotic commercial environment, it helps you to understand where the organisation is heading.

How to plan, budget and forecast when the only constant is change


READ MORE
Philip Tetlock put forecasters under the microscope to distinguish between the good and the great

7 steps to mastering the business of superforecasting


October 2019
October 2019

Read the October 2019 issue of INTHEBLACK magazine.

Each month we select the must-reads from the current issue of INTHEBLACK. Read more now.

CONTENTS